Trinidad Planning Commission Approves Accessory Dwelling Unit Conversion, Sparking Debate on Housing Density

The Trinidad Planning Commission held its regular meeting on June 18th, 2025, addressing several key agenda items, most notably an application to convert existing detached storage space into a livable area. The meeting, a hybrid format with both in-person and remote participants, generated lively discussion regarding housing needs and the appropriate density for the town of Trinidad.

Following approval of the minutes from the March 19th and May 21st meetings, the commission delved into the main agenda item: a permit application to convert existing detached storage space into living quarters. Applicant Sheri sought permission to transform the space, which partially meets the city's definition of a dwelling unit, into a living area. While not intending to create a full Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) at this time, the project raised questions about the definition of "detached accessory structures" and the potential for future rental use. After extensive discussion, which included consideration of concerns about density, the commission approved the permit with a key condition: the space cannot be rented separately from the main house unless a future ADU permit is obtained. Staff will update conditions 5 and 7 to reflect the discussion.

The meeting also included a continued item from a previous meeting. The applicant provided further information regarding the septic system and density of the project, leading to the commission's approval of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) document and the project itself, subject to existing conditions.

Public comment highlighted the diverse perspectives on the issue. Sheri, the applicant, emphasized the need for additional housing in Trinidad and argued the project's compatibility with the neighborhood. Rachel Provolt, a Yurok tribal member and Trinidad resident, and Shari, a development director for the Yurok Housing Authority, both voiced support for the project and highlighted the need for more housing opportunities, although Shari also expressed concern over the density being similar to that of San Francisco. Conversely, Karen Parker, a Trinidad resident, expressed strong objections to the project, citing density concerns and the presence of vacant homes in the area.

The meeting concluded with the approval of the detached accessory structure permit application, subject to conditions, and the continued item from the previous meeting. No specific next steps or deadlines were announced during the meeting.

For those interested in learning more or participating in future Trinidad Planning Commission meetings, agendas and minutes are available at [https://trinidad.ca.gov/document](https://trinidad.ca.gov/document). The meetings are held on the third Wednesday of each month.